Roostica
When you think the Florida Keys - you might not think Pizza - but if you have the craving. Come here.
Owned by the good folks at the Hogfish (last time I checked) - this is a family favorite. Always packed with locals - the food is good and the people friendly. Pizzas a thin crust - and all good. Pepperoni is amazing but SPICY (so don't blindly order a 'roni pie for the kids unless they like it that way.) Sunday nights are family style "Sunday gravy" - with meatballs and sausage. Meatballs are something else - so try em with pasta or on their own.
Wish they'd bring back the big bowl of Caprese Salad. That was awesome.